UPDATE: On hold due to injunction until 31 December 2015
A Missouri Planned Parenthood stopped doing abortions Monday [23 Nov 15], leaving just one abortion site in the state.
The move came after Dr. Colleen McNicholas, who did abortions at the Planned Parenthood business in Columbia, lost her “refer and follow” hospital admitting privileges at the University of Missouri Health Care, according to the Columbia Tribune.
Planned Parenthood Stops Abortions at Missouri’s Second-to-Last Abortion Facility
Hospital admitting privilege requirements have led to a Columbia Planned Parenthood ending its surgical abortion services, leaving the state of Missouri with just one abortion facility.
In September, a University of Missouri Health Care panel voted to cease offering “refer and follow” privileges (which allow doctors to only refer patients but leave patient care to the hospital’s doctors), which were how Planned Parenthood initially obtained the credentials to perform abortions in the state.
The decision would render the Columbia Planned Parenthood’s abortionist ineligible for privileges that satisfy state law, effective December 1, leading to Planned Parenthood’s closure. Now the state’s last abortion facility will be a Planned Parenthood in St. Louis.
The change was partially inspired by ongoing scandal over Planned Parenthood’s sale of organs from aborted babies, though state investigators did not find evidence the Missouri Planned Parenthood affiliate was involved in the organ harvesting business.
Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri CEO, Laura McQuade, said her organization will attempt to pressure the University of Missouri into reversing its decision, and has expressed hope that the U.S. Supreme Court’s upcoming hearing of similar laws in Texas will invalidate it.
On Monday, 40 Days for Life’s Kathy Forck said pro-lifers celebrated the news by releasing one balloon outside of the facility for every abortion performed there since its license was reissued this summer.
[25 Nov 2015, Calvin Freiburger, http://liveactionnews.org/planned-parenthood-stops-abortions-at-missouris-second-to-last-abortion-facility/ ]
[Comment: Just to be clear, Planned Parenthood highly overstates any role it may have had in the resignations of MU System President Tim Wolfe and Chancellor R. Bowen Loftin. For example, of the eight demands made in October by the student-led group Concerned Student 1950, none of them included any reference to Planned Parenthood. Rather, Planned Parenthood is exploiting the disruption at the campus in order to continue abortions at its Columbia facility after December 1. Samuel H. Lee, Campaign Life Missouri, 11 Nov 2015]
Planned Parenthood Seizes Opportunity To Save Abortion Business Before Mizzou Admin Resigns
The embattled health care provider has taken on an unexpected role in the protests at the University of Missouri.
University of Missouri Chancellor R. Bowen Loftin and President Tim Wolfe both resigned their positions on Monday, following massive student-led protests over the university’s handling of racial tensions. Now, Planned Parenthood is urging Loftin to reverse a policy that could greatly restrict abortions in Missouri before he leaves the chancellor’s office for a new role.
Loftin has been criticized for acquiescing to political pressure and revoking Planned Parenthood’s hospital admitting privileges, which allowed the health provider’s center in Columbia to perform medication abortions, in late September. If Planned Parenthood is unable to secure admitting privileges for the one doctor who performs abortions at the center by Dec. 1, Missouri would be left with just one abortion clinic.
“Before assuming a new role, we urge Chancellor Loftin to immediately reinstate the appropriate clinical privileges to ensure there is no disruption in health care access for the residents of this community,” Laura McQuade, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri, said in a statement Monday.
“We are hoping to use this moment to continue to put pressure on the university to reinstate our privileges and ensure services are uninterrupted,” she told The Huffington Post later.
Missouri state law requires doctors who perform abortions to have clinical privileges at a hospital within 30 miles of where the procedure takes place. Anti-abortion advocates say the law protects patient safety in the case of a major complication requiring a hospital transfer, by ensuring that the doctor can follow the patient to a hospital. (Complications from abortions are exceedingly rare and hospitals are obligated in any case to take patients experiencing medical emergencies.)
Abortion rights supporters argue that admitting privileges laws are instead intended to force clinics to close and make abortions harder to obtain, since hospitals often decline to grant privileges out of fears that their staff will be subject to harassment if they do so.
The revocation of Planned Parenthood’s privileges was one of the grievances that student protesters presented to the University of Missouri. Jonathan Butler, a graduate student who went on a hunger strike to protest Wolfe’s actions, cited “Planned Parenthood services being stripped from campus” in a letter explaining why he believed the president had “disrupted the learning experience for marginalized/underrepresented students at the University of Missouri.”
Butler also spoke at a rally in support of Planned Parenthood on campus Sept. 29, as students worked to construct a narrative of racial injustice at Mizzou.
“In Columbia and on the MU campus this has been an intersectional conversation from the beginning,” McQuade said, arguing that racial inequity and health care disparities are intrinsically linked to academic freedom at the university.
If the University of Missouri were to reconsider its decision to revoke the Planned Parenthood doctor’s privileges, it could decide to grandfather her in with her current privileges or give her a different category of privileges. Planned Parenthood is also exploring whether the provider could get privileges at another hospital in Columbia.
In addition to the hospital privileges controversy, scrutiny from state legislatures also led Loftin to cancel contracts with Planned Parenthood that allowed nursing and medical students at Mizzou to complete clinical hours at its health care centers. Last week, a student group delivered over 2,500 signed petitions to Loftin asking him to reinstate Planned Parenthood’s admitting privileges and training contracts.
In another signal of how difficult the climate is for abortion rights advocates in Missouri, Sen. Kurt Schaefer (R), who is running for attorney general, has accused the university of breaking state law by conducting a study of whether Missouri’s mandatory 72-hour waiting period for abortions dissuades patients from having the procedure.
The Republican-controlled Missouri state Senate formed an “Interim Committee on the Sanctity of Life” to investigate Planned Parenthood after videos released by an anti-abortion group showed the health provider’s staff discussing the sale of fetal tissues for medical research. Planned Parenthood says none of its centers make a profit from fetal tissue donation, but state lawmakers have seized the opportunity to investigate the provider nonetheless.
[10 Nov 2015, edited 11 Nov 2015, Samantha Lachman, The Huffington Post, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/planned-parenthood-university-of-missouri_564219bae4b0b24aee4bdd97 ]