Select Page

Baby Tom fought for life for 46 minutes before dying in his mother’s arms.

Mother’s fury over ‘no revival’ policy after seeing 22-week-old son die despite his 46min battle to live (, 16 March 2011)

Fri, 18 Mar 2011

A 22-week-old pre-term baby fought for life for 46 minutes but died in his mother’s arms after hospital staff refused to treat him.

Tracy Godwin gave birth to her son Tom on 6 March last year when she was in the 22nd week of her pregnancy.

But the 31-year-old was left aghast when medics at Southend University NHS Hospital refused to help her son. She had not been told that the hospital does not intervene with babies born under 23 weeks.

Describing the experience she said: “They put him in my arms and he cried and was wriggling around. I could feel him breathing and see his eyelashes and fingers and toes.

“But I kept thinking, ‘Where’s the incubator?’ We were begging the midwives to do something to help him but no one was saying anything. He was not stillborn, he was trying to live.

“If they had tried for an hour and said they couldn’t do anything more for him or he was severely brain damaged, that would have been different, but he wasn’t given a chance.”

Miss Godwin, who was administered the painkiller pethedine, added: “Because of the drug I wasn’t myself and I keep thinking if I hadn’t taken it and withstood the pain, maybe I would have had more fight in me to demand a doctor”.

“We never saw one. It was a disgrace. I just kept crying and crying.

“My partner was shouting at the midwives to help us but they just left us with Tom. We felt so alone, no one was helping us.

“I don’t know when, but I was suddenly aware Tom had gone.”

During a meeting with the hospital after Tom’s death, the grieving parents were told that resuscitating their baby was against hospital policy.

Jacqueline Trotterdale, the hospital’s chief executive, said that an investigation was underway and an apology would be made.

She said: “We follow national guidance not to resuscitate babies born at under 23 weeks and most trusts follow this.

“We need to talk to the mothers and families of these babies to tell them what will happen. This has not happened in a systematic way and this is a big gap we are reviewing.”

Although the NHS offers guidance on when to resuscitate premature babies, individual health trusts can decide whether they wish to follow it.

Earlier this month a leading NHS consultant said that babies born up to 23 weeks should not be resuscitated.

Dr Daphne Austin, Consultant in Public Health Medicine for West Midlands Specialised Commissioning team, believes it is too expensive to do so.

In January, a baby born at 23 weeks and believed to have been the smallest baby born in Britain last year, celebrated her first birthday.

Weighing just 13 ounces and smaller than a child’s doll, baby Willow Ludden-Brooks fought to overcome her slim chance of survival.

But at a happy 10lb 8oz she celebrated her first birthday with her overjoyed family.

[, 16 March 2011]